1. Russia

Window on Eurasia — New Series: Russia Not About to Become an Iran or a North Korea, Nikulin Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, Oct. 12 – It has become a commonplace among many liberal critics of the Putin regime that the current Kremlin leader is promoting the transformation of Russia into something like Iran or North Korea, ideocratic states isolated from the rest of the world, Andrey Nikulin says. But there are compelling reasons why if he tries, he will fail.

            With all its problems, the Russian commentator says, Russia remains far more integrated with the rest of the world than either of those countries were even when their current regimes began the process of cutting them off from the world. Even now, Russians are unwilling to be as isolated as some in the regime would like (

            No Kremlin propaganda will be able to eliminate from Russian mindsets “the conditioned reflect to go to Wikipedia in search of answers to questions” or completely eliminate “the understandings of decency and the beginnings of humanism that Russians have taken from Western culture,” Nikulin says.

            The historical complexity of Russian society and its integration with the West which has shaped the current economic reality of the country makes Russia a very poor candidate to follow the course of Iran and North Korea, and developments in the former show that even if efforts are made to isolate a country they will be opposed and resisted.

            Consequently, the commentator concludes, any effort to move in that direction will “either finish off both society and the country itself” before it gets half way to the Iranian or North Korean ideal and that once those threats become obvious, Russians will turn around out of “a sense of self-preservation and wander back to a dull future lit by Western suns.”

Window on Eurasia — New Series

WP Radio
WP Radio